All In One Collectibles - Randolph, New Jersey

Miles R.

I’m basing my review off of my first time visit. I was skeptical at first due to some of the negative reviews. I started my Pokemon Base Set Unlimited 1999 collection here. They had a draw labeled Pokémon and it was easy to browse their inventory. They also had shadowless, XY and other sets. I enjoyed the vibes and so did my fiancé. Reminded me of the card stores I used to visit as a kid. Awesome vintage comic books, cards, toys and much more. The gentleman behind the counter was flooded with customers but still managed to keep a mental que of who was waiting for assistance. Behind the counter they had the holograms I was looking for. I also really appreciated that they had sticker prices on everything. The lady who cashed me out was very kind and thanked me for my patience even though it really wasn’t a long wait. She also gave me a nice discount on the cards even though I already thought the prices were very fair. It did make me feel great and put a smile on my face. It made my day. I hope to return when I get the chance. Thank you!

Nicole Z. ?. H.

Dont understand bad reviews.
Came in looking for bloomburrow cards. Employee was super nice and helped me find everything I needed. Gave my kid a pokemon sticker since she kept talking about pikachu (she loved it was ecstatic) and we bought a beanie baby. Prices are extremely reasonable for everything and the best I’ve seen compared to the card store at the mall.

10/10 will come back just to support the shop great people.

Cullen W.

As a Pokémon collector I always go to this store and go back to my house happy. This is an awesome place with Nice staff and great products. This has a wide selection of collectible product, such as sports cards, you gi oh (I don’t know if I spelled that correctly) and Pokémon cards. This has great stock in a lot of things and is always Adding new things to their store. Also, the prices are great. I got a pack of Pokémon cards that is usually around seven dollars For almost 3! I would recommend the store to anyone interested in collectibles and it is a great place.

CWM

Genuinely rude staff and an unwelcoming atmosphere. I never knew this shop existed until recently and as an avid Pokemon/Comic fan I have come in a few times to buy product and attempt to sell my own. If you are looking to trade/sell this is NOT the shop to go to. Go to all around retro in rockaway instead. I personally haven’t had bad interactions with the staff or owner because I am polite, but I can definitely vouch for these other reviews that he barely looks at the cards (while he’s in the middle of something else, sometimes doesn’t even come out) and then makes egregious offers. This is not a sell and trade store, but if you are going in for product it’s not too bad. Lots of old sports packs, good singles and slabs, some overpriced Japanese Pokemon packs but other than that a decent selection. Very unwelcoming vibes in there though, the staff do not seem like they want to be there or make money at all.

Michael R.

All In One Collectibles is an amazing source for collectibles, with an extremely friendly, knowledgeable, and outgoing staff always willing to help. However, after stepping into the store today, it's time to call out something wrong and to take a step back from my hobby.

The newest Pokemon TCG set, Prismatic Evolutions, released today. For those unaware, the hype, volatility, and interest for this set is the largest Pokemon has seen in years. This set is next to impossible to find online for MSRP due to scalpers. In the past, All In One Collectibles has always had fair prices - even for more popular sets with limited supply, their prices were never more than $10-$15 above MSRP. My hope was for this set to receive this same treatment from All In One. I was wrong.

ETBs that retail MSRP for $55 were $119.99 at All In One, and the binder collections had a similar double price increase over MSRP. I didn't notice the price increase for other Prismatic Evolutions products, but my guess is a similar increase. It's sad to see them get caught up in the mindset of making a quick buck like everyone else selling Prismatic Evolutions that's not Walmart, Target, Best Buy, etc.

As a business, they are allowed to charge whatever prices they see fit. I can't say for certainty why the prices for this set are higher here, there can certainly be extenuating circumstances (their supplier could charge higher for this set, for example), and I understand it's harder than ever before to get your hands on good product, especially over the past several months. However, when a consumer sees a store setting prices in this manner, it makes it hard for them to want to go back.

SomeGuyWithASubie

Huge place, easy can spend hours looking at everything. Big on collectables,comics and magic the gathering. Pokemon selection was great for singles.

Matt A.

Lies & slander to save a Buck.

(EDIT Response to store owner: 4.65% card fee & Wrong, Mike. I never tried to take the cards off the cardboard. They came wrecked from your case. You left me no choice but to get firm with you when you demonstrated a complete lack of character. Your bad reviews all say the same thing. You're crooked. You owe me $5.45 and I will get it.)

Bottom line: Be aware of who you're dealing with before you shop here. Take singles out of wrappers (store re-sealed) before purchasing or don't buy. 2nd visit was such a bad experience with the owner that we argued and threatened each other. He knew this review was coming and no doubt has a rebuttal ready to paint me as w/e, but I don't care, this was my experience, take away what you will.

Long story:
Bought some damaged product from display case, called to return, explained to whomever answered, he understood & said bring it back to see Mike the owner. So I do. I introduce myself, shake hands, & explain. Immediately: No not us, not our fault, I could never miss this, you couldn't, etc. I try and say that it's okay you missed it it happens just give me my money back. Nope, not one iota of effort to work with me or compromise. I want a good relationship, I try and start over amicably, he wouldn't hear a word of it, again refusing any & all responsibility for selling the cards that way. He started trying to punch holes in anything I said, talked over me, and grasped at anything- like PSA grades aren't what they state and even 10's have some damage..

Few things upset me like businesses not taking accountability and saying: too bad, not our problem, we acknowledge you didn't get what you paid for but we're going to keep your money, and do Zero to rectify anything. So when he took that stance, it struck a nerve and things became less than polite. Told him he's going to take it & give me a refund, or I leave a review, start the charge-back process, and if that fails take him to small claims- which I absolutely would've, legal doesn't cost me a dime.

He relented and said he'd take care of it, but instead of ending the interaction there, he refused to stop talking and made me stand there until he was done preaching & talking down to me. He was enjoying it. Like dude, I don't care; you sold me junk and can't own a mistake, just give me my money back and let's forget each other exist. Nope. That's when the accusations STarted: I did it, then did it on purpose to return & buy elsewhere, shouting YOU OBVIOUSLY NEED THE 50 BUCKS MORE THAN I DO at me, jabs like "don't know if you can see with the glare," (mocking me & referencing how I couldn't see the damage on the card through the plastic they resealed it in with glare. Pics. *confirmed re-sealed twice before I get accused of makin this up too, or, for the sky falling) I don't want customers like you, and all kinds of unnecessary carrying-on.

Now off the soapbox, he gets his wallet and throws 50 bucks cash at me. I ask about the tax and processing fees, he scoffs and doesn't expect me to know there's he has a 4.65% fee for paying with card. He adds that he'll sue me if I attempt a chargeback. Well I am doing a charge back for the taxes and fees you owe me. You can be sure of that. I'm not shady, but I will fight those who are, Tooth & Nail, Mike. Don't you dare accuse me of your mistake, on your product.

Icing on the cake; as I'm walking out the guys around him start shouting weird passive-aggressive remarks at me. Don't know what they were, or care, but I said enjoy the review and left.

So that's what you're dealing with at this establishment.
If you have the time and tolerance, knock yourself out.
If you DON'T WANT A HEADACHE, shop elsewhere.

Chuck M.

Just happend to be at this mini strip mall during an event at this Store. I went in to check it out and discovered a really cool store with something for everyone. They carried a wide range of collectables from sports to toys. From.comics to costumes, they have it all. Will be working on starting a horror collection and this will be my go to store for sure. Great staff, super friendly and engaging. Great place, look forward to going back.