Missing Piece - Puzzle Exchange - Westminster, Colorado

Haley Jenkins

I love this whole concept! What a great opportunity to puzzle without the price tag of new puzzles. I loved visiting the store and seeing their huge collection in person. Ladies were incredibly helpful and kind!

Julia Sears

I purchased the Denver Puzzler package with unlimited puzzles. You can select up to 4 to rent at a time, and they are ready within the next business day. If you are in the Denver area, this is an unbeatable deal. I used to have a puzzle subscription through the mail with Completing the Puzzle, and the Missing Piece Puzzle Exchange is significantly better! With Missing Piece you get to choose your puzzles, it’s cheaper if you are in/near Denver, and the system to report missing pieces is better. Hands down, I would highly recommend it if you are looking for a puzzle rental service.

Ambra Taylor

I am local so I am able to pick up my puzzles from the store. Everyone was very helpful and kind as I browsed my way through the huge puzzle selection. My husband and I really enjoyed putting together our first rented puzzle this week. It is nice knowing we don't have to find more places to store puzzles in order to enjoy a large variety.

Rachel Ruble

This puzzle subscription service is awesome! They have a large selection of puzzles to choose from, they ship very fast, and returning the puzzles is easy. I’m so glad I found this service and highly recommend it to any puzzle fanatics who want to try out a lot of different puzzles without the clutter/expense of buying them outright.

Laura Mitchell

Love having puzzle rentals as an option! Great puzzles (only quality brands) and super friendly. Can’t wait to try more of their library.

Jenna Bucien

They have a wide selection of puzzles, and the rental price is excellent. Our puzzle pack arrived within a week. So far we’ve completed one puzzle, and all the pieces were there and in great condition. Can’t wait to continue puzzling!

Lynn Montgomery

Absolutely love that we can go pick out puzzles and support a local business! My husband and I were going through one or two a week and having to buy new ones and the puzzle package allows us to rent them for much cheaper than buying them. Erin was great explaining the whole process in the store. We picked out four together and have already completed one which was great quality. We can't wait to go back and pick out more once we complete these!

Sonya P.

This was my first time using a puzzle rental service, but I decided to try it because I'm running out of room in my closet to store them.

I ordered the mini-puzzle pack, both puzzles arrived together in the same box. Each was in its own zip-lok bag and labeled. There was also a laminated picture of the each finished puzzle for reference.

The first puzzle I did was only 500 pieces but, unfortunately, was missing one piece. The second puzzle had 1000 irregular-shaped pieces, some of which were tiny but they were all there.

Overall, I really enjoyed using this service. The instructions were clear and easy to follow. The puzzles were in good shape and did not appear to be dirty. It gives me the opportunity to put together puzzles that I wanted to try but not buy previously. Good service, highly recommended.